An informal poll on Rosner’s Domain in Haaretz (Shmuel Rosner is chief U.S. correspondent for Haaretz) asking about Israeli military-ordered sanctions on Gaza shows the following results:
Poll Question: Is it legitimate for Israel to cut electricity to the Gaza Strip?
No way, people live there – 45%
Maybe as a temporary tool – 10%
Yes, Gaza is not Israel’s problem – 13%
Sure, and water too – 32%
Votes: 420
This poll can be viewed on Haaretz’s website here.
Another Haaretz story reports that “Late Thursday, Israel cut back around one percent of the power it supplies to Gaza, Defense Ministry spokesman Shlomo Dror said. Israel will continue gradually scaling back electricity until the territory’s Hamas rulers end the rocket fire, he said Friday. ‘It’s their choice. They need to choose if they want to keep investing in
rockets and in attacking Israel or if they want electricity from Israel’, Dror said. Hamas said Friday it would not be deterred by Israel’s cutback of the power supply to the Gaza Strip, as militants continued to bombard southern Israel with Qassam rocket fire. ‘The Zionist enemy must understand that the policy of assassinations, of attacks, of embargo, of cutting electricity and fuel will not halt the resistance and will not break the back of the Palestinians’, said a senior Hamas official, Ismail Radwan. ‘We warn them of a large volcano that will erupt if their aggression increases’. The electricity cut, in which the flow on one of the 10 high-tension wires into the territory was cut by five percent, was the first since the Supreme Court approved cuts in the supply of electricity to the Gaza Strip as a legitimate means of economic pressure – a move sharply criticized by human rights groups. Thursday’s reduction in the supply of electricity marks the beginning of an incremental process aimed at gradually deepening those cuts and reducing Gaza’s dependence on Israel, Israeli officials said. They said the decision to step up cuts in electricity supplies will depend on security assessments and the humanitarian needs of the population there, and may include more power lines. During the first week, the supply will drop by one megawatt of the total of 124 MW Israel supplies the Strip. Israel aims to eventually lower the amount of electricity it supplies the Gaza Strip to a mere five percent of the original total. Human Rights Watch said Israel’s electricity cuts ‘amount to collective punishment of the civilian population, and violate Israel’s obligations under the laws of war’. It said the cuts are affecting civilian infrastructure such as hospitals, water-pumping stations and sewage-treatment facilities. Infrastructures Minister Benjamin Ben-Eliezer said Friday that the human rights groups should be out protecting the children of the Negev who are being targeted by Qassam rockets. Israeli security sources described Thursday’s move as gradual and proportional, stressing that the defense establishment would keep its commitment to the Supreme Court not to undertake actions that would result in a humanitarian crisis in the Gaza Strip. ‘We need to diminish the dependency of the Gaza Strip on Israel in a variety of areas’, Deputy Defense Minister Matan Vilnai said Thursday during a visit to Sderot and Ashkelon. ‘The Supreme Court ruled that on the matter of the electricity we are acting properly. Our intention is to begin to lower the electricity supply in moderate amounts, while the residents of Gaza build the infrastructure for an independent supply of electricity’, he added. The Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem criticized Vilnai’s remarks Thursday, saying that his ‘statements that the aim of the cuts is to assist the Strip to free itself from dependence on Israel is a new peak of cynicism and contradicts the arguments made by the state before the Supreme Court. At this stage Israel prevents the Gaza Strip from developing its independent energy supply – which has caused a deficit of 20 percent in the electricity supply in the Strip, compared to the needs of the population’.” This Haaretz article is posted here.
Israel’s YNet reported that U.S. State Department spokesman Tom Casey told journalists: “We understand