Israeli human rights groups testify to Turkel Commission on Flotilla fiasco

Three of Israel’s most distinguished and respected human rights groups testified before the Israeli-government-appointed Turkel Commission on Wednesday in a six-and-a-half hour marathon public session (with two 10-minute breaks).

One Israeli media report afterwards described the rather mainstream groups [(1) B’Tselem(2) Physicians for Human Rights-Israel, and (3) GISHA] as “left-wing”, and B’Tselem’s Director Jessica Montell as a “radical leftist activist”, — which says a lot about the atmosphere in the country. See story here

The polarization increased geometrically after the massive Israeli military operation in Gaza, Operation Cast Lead [27 December 2008 to 18 January 2009] — during which Israel first announced its formal naval blockade of Gaza’s maritime space, on 3 January 2009, as the ground phase began.

And, the polarization was all too obvious in Wednesday’s hearing.

The Turkel Commission [website here – H/T to Jessica Montell] says it is an independent public inquiry looking into what they call the “maritime incident” of 31 May 2010 [or, the Flotilla fiasco] which occurred in the pre-dawn hours that day when Israeli naval missile boats and helicopter-borne Israeli commandos intercepted the Freedom Flotilla, and killed 9 men [8 Turkish, one American high-school student from a Turkish family] on board the larger Turkish passenger ship, the Mavi Marmara.

It is Israel’s main state-appointed body of inquiry on this matter, which was one of the main news stories in the world for several weeks.   An outpouring of international criticism followed the brutality of the interception.

GPO photo

The Commission’s website notes that it “was asked to relate to an assessment of the security circumstances of placing the maritime closure on the Gaza Strip and the maritime closure’s compatibility with the rules of international law”.

Continue reading Israeli human rights groups testify to Turkel Commission on Flotilla fiasco

International Women's Day, Part Two

For Valentine’s Day, and at the special request of the Dutch government, you may recall, and as we wrote here earlier, the Israeli Military’s Coordinator of [Israeli, of course] Government Activities in the Territories (known as COGAT — and yes, this is part of the Ministry of Defense) allowed 25,000 carnations to leave the Gaza Strip and even went so far as to allow them to arrive in Europe in time for the romantic holiday.

Later reports indicated that even double that amount — some 55,000 carnations, actually — reportedly made it to the European markets just in time for Valentine’s Day.

That was the first export allowed out of Gaza in over a year.

Gaza’s economy was previously based on export of produce (and, when allowed, of human day-labor).

Now, COGAT has reported, “135,000 carnations were exported this week from Gaza to the European market at the request of the Dutch government”. This must have been for International Women’s Day, of course! (This has not gotten the same little surge of coverage that the Valentine’s Day carnations received — is this boring already?)

GISHA, the Israeli human rights organization that has passionately persisted in challenging in Israel’s Supreme Court as collective punishment, illegal collective punishment — and as immoral folly — the Israeli Military closure and the Military-administered sanctions imposed on the Gaza Strip to punish Hamas, has now produced a short animated spot trying to illustrate aspects of the closure and sanctions.

Closed Zone - animation for GISHA
Continue reading International Women's Day, Part Two