Here, we are told, there are other problems that are bigger, more important, more pressing than pollution and the environment. “Politics”, for example, is both the explanation of what is wrong, and of why we can do nothing about it.
Yet, every hour of every day, the problem is growing.
Who do Palestinians think is going to clean up after them?
Why can’t Palestinians take care about their garbage, and throw it away properly?
Here, in Jerusalem, the conventional Palestinian wisdom is that the “municipality” — that is, of Jerusalem, Israel — refuses to come to Palestinian areas because (1) they discriminate against Arabs, (2) have an enormous disdain for Palestinians, or (3) are afraid of Palestinians.
The municipality takes our money (Arnona, the municipal tax), but refuses to provide us services, many Palestinians say. A few Palestinians say: we pay Arnona, but we refuse to ask the municipality for services, because we may be accused of “collaboration”.
In the meantime, the landscape of Palestinian areas is littered — littered — with garbage. It is, I am sorry to have to say, disgusting.
Our efforts to conduct an informal poll about this, it must be reported, have resulted in more resentful or sullen silences than useful answers.
You can just imagine the confused and very annoyed reactions I’ve gotten when I ask, provocatively, “Who do Palestinians think is going to clean up after them, their Mothers?”
In a local shop, I said no thank you, I don’t need a plastic bag for my purchases — and I was told, with the best of intentions — that it was unseemly for a lady to walk around with her purchases, without a plastic bag. So, I will do what I did in Geneva, which is to carry my own bags when I am going shopping. Except for when I forget.
Large parts of the urban and suburban Palestinian landscape is littered with blowing plastic bags — mainly blue, or black — mainly in the hot and arid days of summer.
Plastic bags are caught in the branches of trees, and remain there.
Workmen who came to my new apartment would open packages of supplies — and then throw them on the floor of my apartment. I was supposed to pick up after them! Could they really have no idea how insulted I felt? Well, no, explained one friend — if they were working in the home of a rich person, they would do a terrific clean-up after themselves. So, it is an issue of respect, as I suspected.
And so, as suspected, this garbage problem is a real manifestation of a general lack of respect …
A real and effective political struggle would have to deal with this. And the real liberation of Palestine will have to have a real struggle against throwing garbage everywhere, without picking it up!
It is noticeably cleaner in the West Bank than in East Jerusalem and its suburbs. (Of course, it is clean in West Jerusalem. But Israel does have quit a lot of pollution issues –particularly untreated sewage, and not only along its Mediterranean coast…
A friend who lives in Beitin village, just outside Ramallah (but now a 45-minute drive away, rather than the 3-minute drive it always was before, because of Israeli blocked roads to protect the growing Israeli settlement of Beit El) said that the municipal council leader has lead a three-year, but eventually successful, campaign against garbage littering in their village. He went to the Mosque, eventually, and made numerous speeches with explanations. After a three-year campaign, there is now progress. But there are still problems, she reports — school children buy small bags of chips after school, and just disdainfully throw the bags right on the ground. (As if they were some big pashas, with slaves to pick up in their wake.) Still, the overall problem is nevertheless reduced. “My sister-in-law used to throw her household garbage (very loosely wrapped in a store’s plastic bag, so that it would splatter on impact) OFF THE ROOF! [n.b., this was 2.5 stories up, above the street.] It was my Mother (the sister-in-law’s Mother-in-law) who changed this, by shouting at her every morning to clean up her garbage”.
Of course, the Mother-in-law has to be progressive, and convinced, as is Umm Tamim …
I just spotted this, on the blog Aquacool, being written by a “transplanted” Palestinian-Jordanian now living with her husband and son in Tunisia: “One can still see people throwing garbage out their car windows; a study showed that Arabs alone throw away around 25 billion plastic bags on daily basis!…”
Continue reading Who do Palestinians think is going to clean up after them, their Mothers?