Pushing the limits in Sheikh Jarrah

The regular weekly Friday demonstration in Sheikh Jarrah got a bit pushy on Friday.

Eight people were arrested [YNet says “detained for questioning”]. Somehow, luckily for them, they were released later on Friday, instead of spending all of Shabbat and more in jail — as happened last winter.

Sheikh Jarrah on 9 July 2010 - photo by Daniel J. Sieradski via Didi Remez on Facebookphoto by Daniel J. Sieradski via Didi Remez on Facebook

YNet reported that “The protestors attempted to enter the Simeon the Just [Shimon Hatzadik] compound, claiming a court had given them permission to do so, but were stopped by police and Border Guard officers. Activists who clashed with the police said the officers used violent means against them despite what they defined as a ‘passive protest’ … [F]ormer Knesset Member Zahava Gal-On (Meretz) told Ynet: ‘The police are shoving everyone. We stood on the pavements and they said our gathering was illegal. We had no one to talk to’. Author David Grossman and former Attorney General Michael Ben-Yair attended the rally as well Knesset Member Zahava Gal-On (Meretz). According to eyewitnesses, Grossman was also pushed by the police”.

For months, protestors have been confined to an area across the street from the entrance to the Sheikh Jarrah area, according to a court decision [in late January?] which, for some months, ended most police action against the demonstrators.

This Friday, things apparently changed: YNet reported that one of the protestors, Shir Sternberg, said: “We have wanted to protest inside the neighborhood with the Palestinians for the past nine months. We have a court approval’. However, if there is a new court order, it was apparently not communicated to the Israeli Border Police and national police”.

This would not be unusual.

However, it’s not yet clear whether or not a new court order exists, or what restrictions it might contain. And, there are suggestions in the accounts posted by participants that they decidedy on their own in advance to try to move forward during the demonstration this past Friday.

UPDATE: There is even more reason to think there might not be a new court order: the entire court system in Israel was shut down for a strike for 2.5 weeks, and the strike ended only on 11 July…

In any case, “A police official told Ynet … that [esteemed author David] Grossman was one of the dozens of protesters who attempted to break through the barrier and enter the Jewish homes. According to the police, the officers ‘used reasonable force’ against the writer and pushed him to an area authorized for demonstrations in accordance with a court ruling”. This YNet report is published here.

Haaretz reported that “The clash erupted when demonstrators tried to make their way to the contested homes in the neighborhood. Gal-On and Grossman said that they were pushed aggressively by police officers. Gal-On said that ‘it was one of the more violent events. We wanted to enter the neighborhood, but the police brutality was unprecedented’. ‘They pushed, and I too got hit’, Gal-On went on to say. ‘They just kicked the young people who were lying on the ground’. Gal-On added that former attorney general Michael Ben-Yair pleaded with the police to calm the situation, but they were uncooperative”. This is reported here.

Max Blumenthal noted on his blog that this was “the most violent repression since the weekly demonstrations began … Though Sheikh Jarrah demonstrators have been arrested en masse in the past, the protest is often a mellow affair characterized by chanting, singing, and kibitzing among a few hundred Jewish Israeli leftists. However, this week the demonstrators demanded to enter the Simeon the Just compound that the police normally cordon off to everyone except settlers”. This is posted here.

Watch news photographers do their job in yesterday's demonstration in Sheikh Jarrah, East Jerusalem!

With thanks to Joseph Dana for his post on his blog here, it is possible to see the Youtube video by Yisrael Putermam of yesterday’s demonstration of Israelis supporting not only evicted Palestinians but also democracy, freedom of expression, and other human rights in Sheikh Jarrah:

In the information posted on the Youtube site alongside the video, Puterman wrote:
“This week the demonstration was even bigger than those of previous weeks. 350 demonstrators, amongst them former minister and Knesset Chair Avraham Burg, former minister Yossi Sarid, MK Muhamad Barak’e and former MK Uri Avneri, gathered in a park near the neighborhood to protest the racist evictions taking place there in spite of intensifying police oppression of the struggle (see last week’s report). Two demonstrators offered the police officer in charge, Avi Cohen, a big bouquet of flowers, thanking him for helping the struggle gain nationwide attention by arresting about 20 activists every week. Cohen refused to accept the flowers and they were left at his feet. After about an hour of demonstrating in a tense atmosphere, demonstrators started marching towards the neighborhood. Border and Riot policemen stopped the march, while still allowing settlers and visitors of the Shimon Hat’sadik Tomb through. After a quarter of an hour police attacked the demonstration, arresting about 15 people and beating on others. The demonstration continued for another two and half hours, with police occasionally beating people and shoving them back, but attempting to avoid too many more arrests. The day ended with 22 arrested. During the demonstration it became apparent that settlers were attacking Palestinians inside the neighborhood, and two residents required medial care. At the same time police raided Palestinian homes and arrested people who participated in the demonstration and then went home. The demonstrators’ protests outside against the police’s siding with the violent settlers were met with yet more police brutality”.